
A student is struggling with transitions, another needs support navigating peer relationships, someone else has difficulty beginning independent work, and three students seem to be having a particularly rough time keeping their hands to themselves. Meanwhile, you’re responsible for delivering instruction, collecting data, communicating with families, attending meetings, and somehow finding time to use the bathroom.
The suggestion to create an individualized behavior plan for every student who is struggling sounds reasonable in theory. After all, we know behavior is complex, students have different needs, and individualized support matters. In practice, the amount of time required to develop, implement, and consistently monitor multiple behavior plans can become completely unmanageable.
I’ve spent enough years in classrooms and working alongside teachers to know that most educators aren’t struggling because they don’t understand the importance of supporting students. They’re struggling because the systems we’ve created often require an extraordinary amount of time and energy to do that work well.
We need approaches to behavior support that recognize the realities of teaching.
Every Behavior Concern Doesn’t Require a Formal Plan
When a student begins demonstrating challenging behavior, there’s often pressure to respond with something tangible. A behavior chart, a tracking sheet, a reinforcement system, or a written plan can feel like evidence that we’re addressing the problem.
Sometimes those tools are appropriate, particularly when a student has significant or persistent needs that require coordinated, individualized intervention. However, many everyday classroom challenges can be addressed through smaller adjustments to instruction, routines, and the environment.
A student who struggles to begin independent work may benefit from having the first step identified before the teacher walks away. Another who frequently interrupts might need an accessible way to capture their thoughts while waiting to contribute. A child who becomes overwhelmed during transitions may need advance notice, a predictable stopping point, or additional processing time.
These supports can be implemented without developing an elaborate system that requires the teacher to track points, distribute rewards, and complete another form at the end of the day.
Of course, students with IEPs, a behavior plan, or other documented supports must receive the services and accommodations outlined in those plans. Significant behavior concerns may also require a functional behavioral assessment or more comprehensive intervention.
The challenge is recognizing when an individualized behavior plan is necessary and when a thoughtful adjustment to an existing classroom routine may be enough.

Start by Looking at What’s Already Happening
One of the most useful things teachers can do when behavior becomes challenging is examine the conditions surrounding it. We spend a lot of time documenting what students do, but often much less time considering what happens immediately before the behavior or what the student may be trying to accomplish or communicate.
For example, a student who consistently leaves their seat during independent writing may be struggling with task initiation, sustaining attention, or generating ideas. Another who becomes frustrated during cleanup might have difficulty shifting attention or organizing materials.
Understanding these patterns can help teachers identify supports that address the demands of the situation. This doesn’t require an extensive data collection system or flushed out behavior plan for every minor concern. Sometimes a few days of brief observations are enough to identify a useful starting point.
Notice when the behavior occurs, what expectations are in place, and whether there are circumstances in which the student is more successful. Then make one manageable adjustment and pay attention to what changes.
Build Supports Into Routines You’re Already Using
The most sustainable classroom supports are often the ones that become part of everyday instruction. Consider a classroom where several students struggle to get started on assignments. Instead of developing separate reinforcement systems for each student, the teacher might introduce a consistent routine for beginning independent work.
Directions are provided verbally and visually, the first step is modeled, and students have a brief opportunity to clarify expectations before working independently.
That routine may benefit students with executive functioning difficulties, multilingual learners, students who need additional processing time, and plenty of other children who simply appreciate knowing exactly where to begin.
Similarly, a predictable transition routine can reduce uncertainty for students who struggle when activities change. Providing a clear stopping point, previewing the next activity, and using consistent language can make transitions more manageable without requiring a separate system for every student.
Universal supports won’t eliminate the need for the kids needing an individualized behavior plan, but they can reduce unnecessary barriers and make the classroom more accessible. They also allow teachers to spend more of their limited time providing additional support to students who genuinely need it.
Make Your Supports Specific Enough to Be Useful
One challenge with classroom behavior support is that we sometimes rely on strategies that sound helpful but are difficult to implement consistently. “Provide frequent breaks” or “offer positive reinforcement” might be reasonable recommendations, but they leave a lot of unanswered questions.
A more useful approach identifies what the support actually looks like.
For a student who struggles with sustained attention, that might mean dividing a 20-minute assignment into smaller sections with a brief movement opportunity between them. For a student who frequently calls out, it might involve providing a notebook where they can record ideas they want to share during instruction.
Specific supports are easier to communicate, implement, and evaluate. They also make it more likely that a student will experience consistency across different classrooms and adults.
This is a big part of why I created this 130 Specific Accommodations resource. Teachers already spend enough time trying to determine what students need, and having a collection of concrete, adaptable supports can make that process more manageable.
The goal is to identify strategies that are realistic for the student and sustainable for the adults responsible for implementing them.

Teach Skills Within the Context of Everyday Classroom Life
Students sometimes need explicit instruction in skills related to emotional regulation, problem solving, communication, and executive functioning. Fortunately, that instruction doesn’t always require a separate lesson or an elaborate intervention program.
A disagreement during group work can provide an opportunity to practice communicating a different opinion. A difficult transition can become an opportunity to teach students how to identify a stopping point. A student who struggles to ask for help may benefit from practicing a specific phrase or using a visual support during independent work.
These moments can be valuable when teachers approach them intentionally and provide opportunities for students to practice skills before they’re expected to use them independently.
Having ready-to-use materials can also reduce the preparation involved. The Behavior Supports Library includes social scripts, visual supports, and hands-on activities that teachers can incorporate into existing routines without having to create everything themselves.
The resources are there to make instruction more accessible for students and more manageable for teachers.
Sustainability Is Part of Effective Behavior Support
A behavior support system can look fantastic on paper and still be completely unrealistic to maintain in a busy classroom. If a strategy requires a teacher to interrupt instruction every few minutes, manage multiple complicated tracking systems, or spend hours preparing materials, consistency is going to be difficult. That’s worth considering when we’re evaluating whether an intervention is appropriate.
Teachers need to be able to implement supports with reasonable fidelity, students need to understand and access them, and the system needs to remain functional during the inevitable chaos of an ordinary school day.
Before creating another behavior plan, consider the smallest meaningful adjustment that could make the situation more manageable. Try it consistently, observe the student’s response, and determine whether additional support is necessary.
Some students will absolutely need comprehensive individualized plans, coordinated services, and ongoing progress monitoring. Those supports are important and deserve adequate time, staffing, and resources. It’s insanely important that teachers lean on their TEAM to support through these more layered situations. No teacher should be bearing the weight of a complex student profile independently. I wrote an entire book on supporting common challenging behaviors sustainably as a TEAM, I’d love for you to read it if you’re looking for resources.
For many everyday challenges, though, teachers can make meaningful progress by strengthening routines, removing unnecessary barriers, and explicitly teaching the skills students need.
We ask teachers to individualize instruction, respond to behavior, support emotional development, and create accessible learning environments, often without providing enough time to accomplish those responsibilities. The solutions we recommend should reflect that reality.
A sustainable behavior support is one that actually gets used, helps the student access what they need, and leaves the teacher with enough capacity to continue teaching.
That seems like a pretty reasonable place to start!!

